By Joe O’Shansky
Just a year after the cannonball of Star Wars we got Richard Donner’s first Superman film. Superheroes, up ’til then, between The Incredible Hulk, Wonder Woman, Green Lantern, Spiderman and Supes, among others, were always a staple of television. Donner’s Superman, and particularly its star, Christopher Reeve, were what defined a superhero movie in 1978.
The thing is, Superman is essentially a Boy Scout from another planet. He’s an immigrant in America who only wants to defend his adopted world from peril. Always doing the right thing. Which, on the whole, makes him a little boring. He doesn’t have much of the darkness and internal strife, despite the loss of his homeworld, that makes a DC character like Batman so compelling.
I guess Snyder and Goyer did the grimdark version with Man of Steel, and they really didn’t understand the assignment (“Hey, maybe he kills Zod? That would be hardcore.”) But at the end of the day, whatever iteration of these archetypes exist—from Superman, to Lex Luthor, to Lois Lane, to Jimmy Olsen and Perry White, over the course of decades—they’ve all been filtered through different creators, for better and worse.
James Gunn’s Superman gets all of them right, realigning who those characters are supposed to be, what a superhero flick is supposed to be, while setting a bar for what a comic book film looks like. He understood the assignment.
For once, it’s not a fucking origin story, and all that is largely handled with a few deft lines of text that drop you right into the here and now. Supes (David Corenswet) has just crash landed in the Arctic after getting his ass handed to him by a robotic foe controlled by Lex Luthor (Nicholas Holt). Meanwhile, Lois Lane (Rachel Brosnahan) is dating Clark Kent (still Corenswet) though she knows his secret identity. When questions about Superman’s true intentions for humanity surface, the people to which he considers himself as one, and beholden to protect, turn against him.
I’ll leave the synopsis there, because you just need to go see it. In a thee-ater. Read that in British.
I don’t know when Gunn started writing this script, but it seems to land at the right time. Societal rifts and the idea that basic human empathy being lost in a bug zapper of media noise, that a propagandist and narcissist with a chip on his shoulder could fool people into not believing the evidence of their eyes and ears. Sound familiar? But really the reason this is kinda the best Superman ever made has less to do with Gunn’s prescience, and more with the execution of his balls-to-the-wall script, a faithful story with fantastic actors who leave everything on the field—as well as being a visual feast of itself. Definitely a plus, but what is still blowing my mind is that I’ve rarely seen a summer tentpole this economically bad ass since Raiders of the Lost Ark.
The not so subtle subtexts under it all; runaway tech, social media (and those megamoguls who want to shape reality), othering immigrants vs. the idea that modern society should be rooted in empathy, an objective truth and justice, like what the American Way (at least in the romanticized, hagiographic sense) used to be, are all well-executed under Gunn’s deft writing and propulsive direction.
The way the characters and the performances are all load-bearing elements of the story seems almost effortless (it’s not) and it’s something you don’t see so much in a CGI-laden actiongasm. Yet here they are. Corenswet brings everything to the role, and I’d be hard pressed to come up with a reason why every version of these iconic characters aren’t the best portrayals in any Superman flick that I’ve ever seen. They’re dynamic and funny as hell.
Superman was always a little boring to me. This is what happens when he isn’t.
9/10